Starting an LLC from scratch often means navigating the overlap between property law and the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC). One common tactic property owners use to avoid accountability is refusing to provide a formal lease agreement. Without a signed lease, they argue that UCC filings cannot be triggered. But the law provides protections even without a signature, and LLC owners need to know how to assert those rights.
---
1. Why UCC Filings Matter
- UCC Article 9 (Secured Transactions): Governs the creation and perfection of security interests in personal property.
- Lease Agreements as Contracts: A signed lease creates a contractual obligation. That contract can serve as the basis for a UCC filing if payments, collateral, or obligations are not honored.
- Public Notice: Filing a UCC‑1 financing statement perfects your interest, making it enforceable against third parties.
---
2. The Property Owner’s Loophole
- No Lease, No Contract: Property owners sometimes avoid signing lease agreements. Without a written contract, they argue there is no secured transaction to trigger UCC protections.
- Default to Property Management Law: In California, when no lease exists, the relationship defaults to landlord‑tenant statutes (California Civil Code §§ 1941–1954). These laws impose duties regardless of a signed lease.
- Habitability Requirements: Civil Code § 1941.1 requires landlords to provide habitable premises (including electricity, plumbing, and safety). Failure to do so creates statutory violations even without a lease.
---
3. Thirty Months of Payments = Tenant Status
- Fact Pattern: Future Octave Records LLC made payments for 30 consecutive months without a written lease agreement.
- Legal Effect: Under California law, acceptance of rent establishes tenancy even without a signed lease.
- California Civil Code § 1941.1: Requires landlords to maintain habitable premises for anyone in lawful possession.
- California Civil Code § 1942: Grants tenants remedies when habitability is violated.
- California Civil Code § 1947.3: Clarifies that acceptance of rent payments—even from third parties—creates tenancy unless explicitly disclaimed.
- California Code of Civil Procedure § 1161: Defines unlawful detainer actions against “tenants” who fail to pay rent or comply with obligations. Payment history itself establishes tenant status.
- Case Law Principle: California courts recognize “implied tenancy” or “tenancy at will” when rent is accepted over time. Thirty months of payments is more than sufficient to establish Future Octave Records LLC as the tenant.
- Conclusion: By accepting payments for 30 months, the property owner legally acknowledged Future Octave Records LLC as the tenant, regardless of whether a lease was signed.
---
4. Hazardous Conditions Strengthen our Case
- Three Months Without Power: Reliance on extension cords is unsafe and violates habitability standards.
- Civil Code § 1941.1: Requires landlords to provide adequate electricity.
- Health & Safety Code § 17920.3: Defines lack of electricity and unsafe wiring as substandard housing.
- Result: These violations justify compensation and can trigger UCC filings even without a signed lease.
---
5. How LLC Owners Can Assert Their Rights
Even if you don’t know every statute, you can still protect yourself by citing the laws in plain language:
- To the Owner:
- “Under California Civil Code § 1941.1, you are required to provide habitable premises, including electricity.”
- “Under California Health & Safety Code § 17920.3, unsafe wiring and lack of power are legally defined as substandard housing.”
- “Under California Code of Civil Procedure § 1161, unlawful detainer applies only to tenants under a lease. Your acceptance of 30 months of payments makes Future Octave Records LLC the tenant.”
- “Under UCC Article 9, I have the right to file liens when obligations are violated, even without a signed lease.”
- Practical Protection:
- Document payments, communications, and conditions.
- Keep receipts and photos of unsafe conditions.
- Assert your rights in writing—letters, emails, or affidavits—so there is a record.
---
6. Conclusion
Property owners may try to side‑step UCC filings by refusing to sign lease agreements. But LLC owners must understand that the law does not allow landlords to escape responsibility. When no lease exists, property management law governs. If those laws are broken, obligations arise by statute, and UCC filings can be triggered without a signature.
By documenting 30 months of payments, citing habitability laws, and asserting rights under UCC Article 9, Future Octave Records LLC is legally recognized as the tenant and fully protected under California law.
---
⚖️ Key Laws Referenced
- UCC Article 9 (§ 9‑109, § 9‑201, § 9‑310) – Secured transactions
- California Civil Code § 1941.1 – Warranty of habitability
- California Civil Code § 1942 – Tenant remedies for habitability violations
- California Civil Code § 1947.3 – Acceptance of rent establishes tenancy
- California Code of Civil Procedure § 1161 – Unlawful detainer
- California Health & Safety Code § 17920.3 – Substandard housing definition